-
Why There's No Single Right Answer (Which Is Actually Useful)
-
Situation A: You Lease Space Under 5,000 Sq Ft
-
Situation B: You Own the Building, 10,000–30,000 Sq Ft, Mostly Daytime Load
-
Situation C: Warehouse, Logistics, or Multi-Meter Site
-
What About a Small Wind Turbine on the Roof?
-
"How Many Watts of Solar Panel Do I Need?"
-
How to Figure Out Which Situation You're In
Why There's No Single Right Answer (Which Is Actually Useful)
I'm the office administrator at a 180-person company. I handle facilities purchasing across three locations — roughly $500K a year, split across about a dozen vendors. So when our ops director asked me to "look into solar," I did the obvious thing: requested quotes from three installers and started comparing.
Wrong first move. All three sized completely different systems for the same building, and none of them explained why. Two months and one $38,000-level roof-structure surprise later, I figured out that the answer depends almost entirely on which situation you're in. So I'm splitting this into the three versions that actually showed up in my quote folder.
If you only remember one thing: figure out your situation before you ask for a quote. Otherwise the quote just confirms whatever you already assumed.
Situation A: You Lease Space Under 5,000 Sq Ft
We have a rented 3,200 sq ft satellite office with four years left on the lease. The energy bill is in the landlord's name and gets allocated by square footage — I don't even have a separate meter read, just a shared allocation number that lands in finance's inbox.
In this situation, my honest recommendation is to wait on the system and put the money somewhere else. There are three hard blockers:
- Who actually captures the savings? If the lease doesn't say, it isn't you.
- The roof isn't yours, and the landlord's warranty may only have five years left on it.
- At four years to lease end, you won't recover equipment cost if you move.
The thing that actually worked for us was the cheapest option: a sub-meter (about $1,800 installed), so we at least got real usage data instead of an allocation. That's roughly two orders of magnitude cheaper than a PV system, and it gave us something actionable for the next lease negotiation — a green clause specifying who installs and who benefits.
Counterintuitive point: for Situation A, the best plan is usually no system at all. Vendors aren't going to tell you that, because it isn't their business to. But if two "energy savings proposals" don't map to your lease structure, don't force it.
Situation B: You Own the Building, 10,000–30,000 Sq Ft, Mostly Daytime Load
This is the case where a solar system usually pencils out. We have an owned 22,000 sq ft office, AC-heavy, load concentrated 8am–6pm on weekdays, mostly lighting and security at night. That daytime profile sits right on top of the solar production curve, so self-consumption looks good.
This is also where I first got into specific hardware — the SMA Sunny Boy 7.7-US-40. I'll be clear: I didn't pick it because it's "the best inverter," I picked it because the specs matched. AC rating 7.7 kW, single-phase, with Secure Power Supply (about 2,000 W max to a dedicated circuit during an outage, assuming sun). That SPS feature turned out to matter for us during two storm outages in the same year.
Here's the detail that almost cost us: 7.7 kW single-phase is residential and very light commercial territory. Our building has three-phase 208V service. Sticking a single-phase unit on that means a transformer or rewiring, and the cost goes up fast. The first proposal put six Sunny Boys on the roof without ever asking about service type. I pulled it, and we went to three-phase Sunny Tripower hardware instead. Plus, the installer never mentioned the DC/AC ratio question until I brought it up.
So when you see a specific model number, check three things first:
- Does the AC rating match your daytime baseload? 7.7 kW is roughly 2–3 small commercial AC units running at once.
- Single-phase or three-phase? Commercial buildings are usually three-phase. The Sunny Boy line is single-phase. Don't fight that.
- What's the DC size? Industry-typical DC/AC ratio is around 1.2–1.4 (meaning a 7.7 kW inverter pairs with roughly 9.5–10.5 kW of panels). Push past 1.5 and you're leaving real production on the table.
Situation C: Warehouse, Logistics, or Multi-Meter Site
Different animal. On one warehouse site I worked through, cold storage plus a row of EV chargers flattened the load curve almost completely, and there were four separate meters to reconcile.
What changes here:
- Inverters are three-phase, 50 kW and up (SMA's Sunny Tripower or larger hardware). Nothing in the Sunny Boy range belongs on this roof.
- The solar battery system calculation flips. It's not about shaving the energy bill — it's about peak demand charges and outage ride-through, and the payback math is completely different.
One thing I learned that vendors don't put in writing: the first quote is almost never the final price on a project of any size. There's negotiating room, usually 8–15% depending on scope. On the warehouse version we got about 11% back on the second round. Treat the first number as an opening position, not a fact.
What About a Small Wind Turbine on the Roof?
This came up constantly in my research — "can we do solar plus wind?" My advice: calibrate expectations way down. Small wind turbines are rated at a specific wind speed (around 11 m/s), and typical suburban or urban roofs see average wind speeds far below that, plus heavy turbulence off the building envelope. Real-world annual output often lands in the low single digits as a percentage of nameplate rating. The Massachusetts Clean Energy Center did multi-site tracking on rooftop turbines and found actual output well under ratings — those reports are public on masscec.com if you want the raw numbers.
Also worth saying: SMA is a solar inverter company. Don't borrow its brand credibility to prop up a wind decision.
"How Many Watts of Solar Panel Do I Need?"
That question focuses on the wrong number. Start with daily kWh, not watts:
Daily kWh ÷ local peak sun hours ≈ DC array size in kW
Concrete version: if that 22,000 sq ft building runs about 60 kWh per day in summer (concentrated on weekdays), and local peak sun hours are roughly 4.5, you're looking at about 13.3 kW DC. But you don't have to build it in one shot — pair a 7.7 kW inverter with around 10 kW of panels, then close the gap with efficiency work or a phase-2 expansion. Don't max out array size just to "cover everything."
And a bit of hindsight: our first proposal skipped the structural roof check entirely. Halfway through design, we found out reinforcement and re-flashing would add about $38,000. If I could redo it, I'd spend $1,500 on a structural engineer's report in week one, before talking systems with anyone. I assumed that was "the installer's job." It is — but not in the order you think.
How to Figure Out Which Situation You're In
Four questions, no consultants needed:
- Own or lease, and how many years left? — Under five years, you're basically Situation A.
- Single-phase or three-phase service, and roughly what capacity? — Single-phase with a light baseload keeps you in Sunny Boy 7.7 territory.
- Daytime or nighttime load? — Daytime is Situation B. Cold chain or heavy overnight is Situation C.
- What problem are you actually solving — bill reduction, outage backup, peak demand, ESG reporting? — The battery answer changes completely depending on which one.
By the time you've answered those four, the shape of the system is usually obvious. The remaining work is just quotes and model selection.
One checkable data point as a sanity reference: SMA's 2023 annual report shows full-year inverter shipments in the neighborhood of 20 GW (Source: SMA Solar Technology AG, 2023 Annual Report; verify the exact figure at sma.de investor relations, since some summaries restate it). The number matters less as a flex and more as a purchasing signal — a supplier moving that volume tends to have parts and service coverage five years out when something breaks, and that's what actually matters to a facilities budget.
Bottom line: all three situations have a "right" answer, and they don't look alike. Find your category first. Do it in that order and you'll spend less — usually a lot less.
Ask a related Maxeon question